NBC is totally uncool with their exclusives. For example, once an exclusive sells out and they "find" more copies, they list them online at flipper prices. They don't hold merch in stores and I don't know of anyone that's been able to order from a brick and mortar location.
I know what you mean. Collecting AFI has always been a fun hobby for me.
The most likely way this will play out is me waiting for a few months after the flipping has died and getting it at a somewhat fair price. The key to collecting is patience. Based off of the pricepoint, pressing numbers, and availability of the last repress, I'm valuing this to me at $40 shipped MAX.